← Back to Logic Problem Lessons

Interactive lesson

Recognizing Contradictions

When an assumption makes a known fact impossible, the assumption must be wrong

Sometimes no clue gives you an immediate match. You can carefully test one possibility and follow what it would force. If that chain collides with a clue or creates two matches where only one is allowed, you have found a contradiction.

Try it yourself

The After-School Club Schedule

Maya, Owen, and Priya each attend a different club—art, chess, or music—at Time 1, 2, or 3.

We will temporarily assume that Owen attends at Time 2. Follow that idea until it either works or contradicts a clue.

1 The chess club meets at Time 2.

2 Owen attends immediately before Priya.

3 Maya does not attend at Time 1.

4 Maya attends the music club.

Temporary assumption: Owen attends at Time 2. Question marks are possibilities being tested, not confirmed matches.

Who attends each club?

PersonArtChessMusic
Maya
Owen
Priya

Who attends at each time?

Person123
Maya
Owen
Priya

? assumption × impossible ✓ match

Step 1 of 4

If Owen attends at Time 2, when must Priya attend?

Use Clue 2: Owen attends immediately before Priya.