← Back to Puzzle Choices

Storied logic puzzles

Sherlogic Mysteries

Find the clues woven into each story, complete the deduction grids, and answer the final question to close the case.

Five properly dressed medieval castle residents examine five tagged keys hanging on the wrong hooks inside a dark, damp key chamber with crumbling stonework, moss, and dripping water.
Medium Featured Mystery

The Missing Castle Keys

Match five castle residents with the rooms they entered, their metal-tagged keys, and the wrong hooks where the keys were found, then expose a forbidden visit to the Treasury.

Solve this mystery
An old-timers baseball exhibition erupts at a nostalgic community ballpark as a right fielder and four other witnesses watch an apparent home run near the wooden scoreboard and right-field fence.
Easy

The Home Run That Never Left

Match five honest witnesses with their ballpark roles, decisive moments, and physical findings, then explain an apparent home run that the batted ball never completed.

Solve this mystery
Five costumed historical performers gather beneath moonlit arches during a lively museum evening, with protected artifacts in glass cases and five symbol-marked cloakroom tickets on the counter.
Medium

The Museum After Midnight

Match five performers with their historical characters, claim-ticket symbols, and starting galleries, then discover why five museum articles only appeared to be stolen.

Solve this mystery
Five friendly scarecrows wearing different hats present directional signs among autumn hedge-maze paths, pumpkins, colorful leaves, and glowing lanterns.
Easy

The Hedge Maze’s Polite Scarecrows

Match five gardeners with their autumn maze junctions, hats, and courteous signs, then identify the one scarecrow that lies.

Solve this mystery
Five autonomous service robots move through the domes, towers, and illuminated corridors of the established Musk Haven colony beneath the red Martian sky.
Medium

The Musk Haven Paradox

Match five Mars-colony robots with their assignments, work locations, and diagnostics, then stop a disaster predicted 72 hours in the future.

Solve this mystery
Five distinctive Old West poker contestants sit at the Silver Spur table while Sheriff Holt studies them beneath a railroad bridge plaque.
Medium Featured Mystery

The Stranger at the Silver Spur

Match five guests with their gunslinger aliases, distinctive hats, and celebrated exploits, then expose the stranger at the table.

Solve this mystery
Five young soapbox derby drivers and an official examine the empty inspection bay where the red Crimson Comet disappeared, with four colorful racers still inside the barn.
Medium

Who Stole the Crimson Comet?

Match five drivers with their homemade racers, late-night errands, and evidence, then identify who hid the missing Crimson Comet.

Solve this mystery
Five equally suspicious community-theater actors discover a pink crown, torn treasure map, glued pocket watch, missing dagger, and rubber chicken among their sabotaged props.
Medium

The Community Theater Prop Sabotage

Reconstruct opening night’s sabotaged productions, props, and actors, then identify who tried to ruin the show.

Solve this mystery