Sherlogic Mystery
A storied logic puzzle. Read closely—every detail may matter.
Case File · Read Carefully
The Case of the Borrowed Automobile
An Overdue-Rent Sort of Case
My office rent was six days overdue when Cecil Whitmore arrived with enough indignation to fill the room. His dark-green touring automobile had vanished from outside Richmond’s Briarwood Hotel on Saturday evening. Police found it before dawn in an abandoned carriage house west of the city. Nothing had been stripped or sold, but the left front fender was freshly dented, its tires carried red clay, and a bright-green streak marked the damaged metal. Whitmore called it the work of a professional thief. The evidence suggested someone much closer to home.
Five Earlier Borrowings
Five people admitted using Whitmore’s automobile once during the preceding workweek: chauffeur Arthur Bell, Whitmore’s sister Eleanor, nephew Thomas Vale, business partner Harold Crane, and housekeeper Margaret Doyle. Each drove on a different day from Monday through Friday, visited a different destination, left a different object behind, and returned with a different bit of damage. Reconstructing those trips would show who already had a suspicious connection to the evidence found Saturday night.
Arthur and Eleanor
Arthur Bell said his trip had been to Riverside Garage. The work gloves found in the automobile were his, and he remembered tightening—but not fully securing—the left headlamp before returning the machine. Arthur drove exactly one day before Eleanor. The Monroe Hall trip occurred exactly one day after the Riverside Garage trip. An opera program was left after the Monroe Hall visit, when a hatpin tore the rear upholstery.
The Last Three Days
Harold Crane used the automobile on Thursday and went to Union Station. His baggage check slipped beneath a seat, and a nail near the freight entrance punctured one tire. Margaret Doyle drove on Friday to Broad Street Market. She left her wicker basket in the rear compartment and cracked the side mirror while passing a delivery wagon. Thomas Vale used the automobile earlier in the week than Harold but later than Eleanor.
A Familiar Combination
The remaining weekday trip was to Lakeside Pavilion. A dance card was left in the automobile, and the driver scraped a freshly painted green service gate. On Saturday night, the police found another Lakeside dance card beneath the driver’s seat. Its cloakroom stub bore Thomas Vale’s name and described a blue overcoat. A blue wool thread clung to the broken latch of the carriage house.
Seventeen Unexplained Miles
Arthur’s Saturday service entry recorded 1,284 miles. Whitmore then drove five miles—first taking Eleanor to Monroe Hall and then continuing to the Briarwood Hotel. The odometer read 1,306 when police recovered the automobile, leaving seventeen miles unexplained. The city map supplied exactly seventeen: seven miles from the hotel to Lakeside Pavilion, a two-mile detour forced by the pavilion’s closed west road, and eight miles from Lakeside to the abandoned carriage house.
The Streetcar Alibi
Thomas admitted attending Saturday’s dance but insisted he traveled both ways by streetcar and never touched the automobile. The streetcar company’s notice told a different story: a fallen electrical line halted all Lakeside service from 8:35 until 11:20. The pavilion gatekeeper reported that a dark-green touring car struck the green service gate at 9:50. Margaret saw Thomas walk home shortly after 10:30; his blue overcoat was torn, and one sleeve carried a smear of green paint. Complete the weekday record, then decide who borrowed the automobile Saturday night and hid it after the accident.
Detective’s note: There is no separate clue list. Circle the useful facts in your mind and transfer them to the grid.
Detective’s Deduction Grid
Record the relationships you uncover in the case file.
Eliminate is selected.
LogicPuzzles.com